Response from Justice Now: You've guessed wrong! Justice Now is not politically motivated and has also highlighted cases of injustice involving Democratic Albany County DA David Soares. Justice Now has also raised issues in cases as far as Cooperstown. Admittedly there is a strong focus on Rensselaer County DA Patricia DeAngelis, but only because she gives those of us that respect the order of law so much to talk about. We should add that many members of Justice Now did attend the Carroll trials or have reviewed the entire trial transcript from both Carroll trials. We welcome you, in fact urge you, to do the same.
As stated on this website, DA DeAngelis told the second set of 12 jurors that Jack Carroll had not raped his accuser, despite the fact that her unethical antics convinced the first set of 12 jurors that Carroll was guilty of those admittedly fabricated charges. Considering that DeAngelis admittedly convinced 12 jurors that Carroll was guilty of a fabricated crime, is it really that hard for you to imagine that she was able to convince a second group of 12 jurors that Carroll was guilty of a fabricated crime??
2/17/05: If the circumstances surrounding this case were as clear cut as the previous postings would indicate, why would Jack have lost not one, but two cases?
Noticeably absent from the previous postings are details surrounding his felony conviction for tax evasion (which certainly couldn't have helped his credibility) and certain details about Jack's questionable meetings with Mary Carroll during the trial during which we can only theorize that he and Mary...
2/11/05: I am beside myself with the outcome of this case, re. Jon Romano. I am ashamed that I live in a county with DeAngelis for a DA. Jon Romano is a sweet and caring boy who suffers from depression and was on medication, which the FDA has already admitted causes violent and suicidal behavior in teens. This fact was totally ignored. This does not surprise me though. DeAngelis has traumatized my daughter ... during the grand jury proceedings. She screamed at my daughter when she asked why his mental health would not be given consideration, saying, "Christina Wilhelm who drowned her children was not crazy either." When we were seated at her desk in her office, she had my daughter in tears while she screamed at her. Then she had the nerve to tell my daughter she was going to issue an order of protection so my daughter could not visit her best friend Jon and possibly discuss the case with him. Such orders are not for the prosecutor's benefit but for a victim's. She stood up looming over us as we sat. I then stood as well and told her I would not tolerate any such order and we followed up by attending his arraignment and told the judge we did not want it. There is so much that went wrong with this case from the beginning. Minor students were questioned without parents being present; I was refused access to my child during questioning, as were other parents.
I am appalled that Judge McGrath allowed this sentence to stand. I hope they do not plan to run for re-election. However that is not enough. My child has suffered repercussions for her support for Jon, from dirty looks from teachers and principals to on-line threats and hate mail. My child sees that school officials have ... totally ignored Jon instead of getting him the help that the law requires them to do, hence an environment where she cannot trust the school is preventing her from seeking counseling at the school. It is ironic that the statements read by DA DeAngelis in court were mostly from those who are planning to sue for damages. ... She has set a dangerous precedent for defendants with mental illness. Where in hell is the state Mental Health Department when all this occurs? It is all political and she has put a stain on democracy and justice in our county. Thank you.
12/09/04: My family is looking for help getting our 17 year old daughter's probation terminated and her criminal record expunged. She was in treatment for the past several years, diagnosed with depression and oppositional defiance disorder (and was given just about every drug there is for treatment). Her behavior intensified to an unmanageable state about three years ago where her condition manifested itself in self-mutilization, suicide attempts and verbal and physical violence against my husband and myself and each time ended in staring spells where she became totally unresponsive. She was put on PINS, hospitalized several times in an adult psychiatric unit and at a local treatment center, lived in a voluntary agency for 2 months, lived at a shelter on 3 or 4 separate occasions, and after the last event, was placed in a detention home for two months and then placed in school for girls for one year (where we were required to pay $240.00 a week in child support to the county).
During these events, she was arrested three times (1 to keep her put until a Family Court hearing and 2 for assaulting us - on the 2nd assault arrest she was sentenced as an ADULT, has a CRIMINAL RECORD and is currently on PROBATION. Over this period I asked her doctors and therapists several times if they thought that Nichole may have a seizure disorder only to be told that she has no history of seizures. But in February 2004, while still in the school for girls, she had a grand mal seizure playing a video game. All of her anti-depressant medication was discontinued (which included Wellbutrin, which never be given to people with a seizure disorder).
Interestingly, my daughter's depression and aggressive behavior totally disappeared after her grand mal. She was examined by a neurologist who ordered EEG's which captured seizure activity and then diagnosed her with complex partial seizure disorder and placed her on anti-seizure medication. Since she has improved 100% and because of a new diagnosis, she was released from placement early. I am perplexed at the ignorance of her many treatment providers for not doing any brain testing. I am frustrated that my daughter went through this terrible ordeal and lost several years of her life suffering from an untreated illness due to a misdiagnosis. (I have found in my research that people have been unduly arrested for aggressive behavior while in the midst of a seizure).
Our family is still recovering from the financial, physical and emotional suffering we went through during this whole episode. Any help or advice you can give us would be greatly appreciated.
Response from Justice Now:
Thank you for your comment. The articles written by Carl Strock are copyright material of the Daily Gazette in Schenectady, NY. A link on our site to the Daily Gazette won't necessarily provide you access to the articles as the on-line version of the Daily Gazette requires a subscription. The Carroll family does have hard copies of the more than 35 articles written by Mr. Strock and is happy to loan you the set if you would like. Or you can contact Carl Strock (518-395-3085) at the Daily Gazette (www.dailygazette.net).
Justice Now also has available for loan, copies of the Dorothy Rabinowitz book No Crueler Tyrannies, Accusations, False Witness and Other Terrors of Our Times, as well as DVD or VHS copies of all Justice Now television shows to date.
The court record in the Carroll case is voluminous- well over 3,000 pages. We are in the process of placing the record on-line but it is a long process and we have run into some technical difficulties. In the interim, the Carroll family offers complete access to hard copies of these transcripts to any interested party. Please send your request through this website and arrangements will be made.
12/05/04: I just want to give my full support to Mr. Carroll and his family. I think our judicial system needs a serious overhaul! Too many children and women file sexual assault charges to get attention, sympathy or due to pressure from authorities. This needs to stop because innocent people are going to jail every day and actual victims are not being taken as seriously as they should be. I firmly believe that anyone that accuses anyone of sexual assault of any kind, be psychologically evaluated while the police look for evidence to support the claim. If they can not find any evidence (including with the rape kits and physical examinations), the accuser's psychological evaluation should then determine whether to pursue or quit the case. The psychological examination MUST be performed by both the defense's psychologist and by the prosecutor's psychologist. If it comes down to the psychological evaluation to determine the outcome, BOTH psychologists MUST be agreed in the decision.
I, personally, have met several women who told me that they had accused men of date rape when they were drunk at a party simply because they were embarrassed that they had slept with this man. Ruining a person's life and reputation just because you are embarrassed to admit that something happened is ridiculous!! Also, these women that make false reports need to be sentenced and put in jail for the crimes that they have committed!! Maybe then, people won't be so quick to accuse. I'm sorry I'm ranting, but this subject greatly upsets me and I feel very strongly that something needs to be done to change this! Thank you for giving us a voice.
Get Involved!!!
Help Justice Now expose cases of injustice and rid the criminal justice system of prosecutors, police, investigators, and judges who contribute to these cases.
We are looking for volunteers to help spread the word and educate the public, and board members to help organize and plan. If you're interested in helping out, or would just like to become a member of this important organization, contact us.
Newsletter
This bi-monthly email newsletter brings you up to speed on the latest cases of injustice, as well as updates on existing cases. It also includes articles, facts and resources concerning the criminal justice system. Included in each edition is a list of current and upcoming events and efforts in the fight against injustice.
If you would like to receive a copy of the nexsletter, just send us a request along with the email address to which you would like the letter sent. Subscribe to Newsletter.